David DownsOctober 17, 2019
A suspected tainted black market vape cart seized in New York. (Courtesy of New York State Department of Health)
As of Thursday, Oct. 17, the CDC has reported 1,479 confirmed and probable cases in 49 states of severe acute respiratory distress syndrome possibly associated with a recently inhaled drug aerosol (commonly known as vaping). As many as 33 patients in 24 states may have died from the condition. The deaths occurred in Illinois, Oregon (2), Indiana (3), California (3), Minnesota, Kansas (2), Missouri, Georgia (2), Florida, Mississippi, Nebraska, New Jersey, Alabama, Virginia, Delaware, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, Utah, Texas, Montana, and Tennessee. Here’s what you need to know.
Should I stop vaping?
- If you own illicit vape cartridges, throw them away immediately. The CDC, FDA, and HHS advised consumers to avoid buying cannabis vapes or using products off the street. They are unregulated, untested, and are often contaminated. On Oct. 4, the FDA said “stop using THC-containing vaping products and any vaping products obtained off the street.”
- If you purchase any disposable vaporizer cartridge—either THC, nicotine, or CBD—and it’s filled with the wrong additive or contaminant, at the wrong amount, using it carries the risk of immediately injuring your lungs.
- More broadly, the American Medical Association said Sept. 9 to stop vaping any electronic drug-delivery device. On Sept. 10, President Trump mulled banning flavorings in legal e-cigarettes.
What is the suspected diagnosis?
- In many cases, symptoms and treatment mirror a condition called lipoid pneumonia, previously found in patients who inhaled mineral oil. Subsequent biopsies of 17 victims indicate “airway-centered chemical pneumonitis from one or more inhaled toxic substances rather than exogenous lipoid pneumonia as such, but the agents responsible remain unknown.”
- “It seems to be some kind of direct chemical injury, similar to what one might see with exposures to toxic chemical fumes, poisonous gases, and toxic agents,” said Dr. Brandon Larsen, a surgical pathologist at Mayo Clinic Arizona who spoke to CNBC. “Based on what we have seen in our study, we suspect that most cases involve chemical contaminants, toxic byproducts or other noxious agents within vape liquids.”
“I think we really have the feeling right now, that there may be a lot of different nasty things in e-cigarette or vaping products. And they may cause different harms in the lung,” a CDC official said Oct. 3.
What’s causing it?
- The contamination is emanating out of the supply chain for illicit market THC vape carts, the CDC said Sept. 19. “Most patients have reported a history of using e-cigarette products containing THC. Many patients have reported using THC and nicotine. Some have reported the use of e-cigarette products containing only nicotine.” On Sept. 27, the CDC stated, “the high level of use of pre-filled THC cartridges, used in a range of different devices, suggests that the cartridges might play an important role.” And Minnesota’s lead investigator said Sept. 24, “so far our investigation is correlating these injuries to THC vape cartridges that are illegally purchased.”
- There are multiple known contaminants in illicit vape carts that can cause lung injury. But New York health authorities have confirmed that synthetic vitamin E (tocopheryl-acetate) is tainting most seized vape carts in that state. Pen makers report using it because it’s a cheap thickener. The FDA is now specifically looking at tocopherols. New York has subpoenaed three thickener-makers—Floraplex, Honey Cut, and Mass Terpenes—after tests showed all three products were tocopheryl-acetate. On Sept. 13, SC Labs of California found Floraplex’s Uber Thick to be almost totally tocopheryl-acetate.
- The FDA has received about 725 samples for testing. So far, they’ve found vitamin E acetate in 47% of the 225 THC carts tested. The FDA is testing seized carts for THC, nicotine, cutting agents called diluents, additives, pesticides, opioids, poisons, and toxins. One New York patient who tested his cart found it contained formaldehyde, pesticide, vitamin E oil, and “a little dab of THC.” The California lab Cannasafe reports ten out of ten vape carts from California illicit stores tested positive for tocopheryl-acetate, some as high as 40%. FDA testing has confirmed tocopheryl-acetate cuts of 31% to 88%, the mean average is 50%.
- Health officials have confirmed that among the tainted carts are ones with the illicit market brand names Dank Vapes, TKO, Off White, Moon Rocks, Chronic Carts, and West Coast Carts, but the condition is linked to multiple illicit market brands across multiple states. One Tulare County, CA victim’s family member confirmed the presence of a “black and gold” cart labeled “Lucky Charms” from the brand “West Coast Cure”. (Matching that description is both counterfeit packaging and authentic packaging for a popular, illicit market brand in California called West Coast Cure.)
Why vitamin E oil?
- As Leafly reported in early September, a new diluent known as Honey Cut entered the illicit vape cart market in late 2018. The product, which dilutes THC oil without thinning the viscosity, is manufactured by Honey Cut LLC registered to a Joshua Temple of Los Angeles. Officials at the terpene manufacturer True Terpenes, based in Portland, OR, told Leafly they tested Honey Cut earlier this year and found it to contain Vitamin E oil, aka tocopheryl-acetate. Two brands—Mr. Extractor of Oregon and Constance Therapeutics of California—told Leafly they’ve been selling forms of vitamin E oil into the vape cart market. Mr Extractor’s Drew Jones told Leafly he believes up to 40 companies sold a copycat oil, and the oil is in 60% of carts in the US. Lab tests have found the oil in multiple thickener products, including Peak Terpenes’ Thicc Stretch.
What are the symptoms?
What are the latest numbers?
- This man-made mass poisoning event is akin to bathtub gin under alcohol prohibition. It is generally a creature of unlicensed markets where consumers have no legal alternative. It’s akin to recent Spice/K2 poisonings, as well as unregulated CBD market poisonings. The first reports came out of the prohibition state of Wisconsin, which has 52 cases, and Kings County, CA, which has banned legal access to tested cannabis, alongside 60% of local cities and counties. California has 133 cases and three suspected deaths (in L.A., Tulare, and Kings County). Illinois has 123 sick and one death. New York reports 125 cases and a death. Texas has 119 confirmed cases. Kansas reports two suspected deaths. Minnesota has 73 cases. Missouri reported one related death Sept. 19, and 22 possible cases. Florida reported 68 illnesses and a death Sept. 24. Georgia reported a death Sept. 25. On Sept. 30, Nebraska reported a May death that appears to fit the CDC’s criteria. New Jersey and Virginia reported a death Oct. 1. Alabama reported a death Oct. 2. Delaware reported a death Oct. 3. Officials also reported deaths in Massachusetts, and New York.
“The data that we’re getting does not suggest this has peaked. It doesn’t suggest that it is declining and we’ll need more observations,” the CDC said Oct. 3
- In contrast, Oregon has two suspected deaths and six suspected illnesses. Colorado has had nine suspected cases for several weeks. The state of Washington may have three cases, with one allegedly linked to a store. California’s second and third suspected deaths occurred in Tulare County and Kings County, where purchasing tested, legal cannabis from a store is banned in all areas other than the city of Woodlake. The victim’s family said he was using illicit market THC cartridges. Of Ohio’s 17 confirmed cases, 90% are black market THC cart-related, and none are medical cannabis system-related.
Why is this happening now?
- Leafly has reported that a new ingredient—next-generation cutting agents (thickeners)—are being misused in THC vape carts. Legal chemical thickener makers said they do not approve of use in vape carts. Chemical thickener makers also do not approve of dilutions greater than 10%. However, their web sites are unclear about the products’ approved and unapproved uses. The chemical makers have no information on what inhaling thickener aerosol does to your lungs, especially if it is heated or burned.
How can I protect myself?
- Only buy tested, regulated adult use and medical cannabis products in legal stores like California, Washington, Oregon, and Colorado. Licensed supply chains are much harder to contaminate. By contrast, street traffickers are filling carts with harmful chemicals, and they go straight into your lungs. Here’s how to spot an illicit market, or counterfeit THC vape cart.
- Though licensed markets have more safeguards, suspicious additives are not yet banned in California, Washington, and Oregon. On Sept. 24, the California Dept. of Public Health told all consumers to refrain from all vaping. On Sept. 23, Massachusetts paused all vape sales statewide. On Sept. 12, Oregon regulators told stores to post vape warnings and hold suspicious products, and told licensed cart markers to immediately admit any “undisclosed agents” or face “legal consequences.” Oregon retailers have begun pulling suspicious products. On Sept. 26, Oregon officials told consumers to stop vaping anything at this time. On Oct. 15, Oregon banned all non-cannabis-derived vape flavorings. On Sept. 27 Washington halted sales of e-cigarette flavorings. And on Sept. 26 Colorado dispensary chain Medicine Man stated that it had “removed all vape products containing propylene glycol or vitamin E acetate from its shelves effective immediately.” Colorado plans to ban the vape additives tocopheryl-acetate, polyethylene glycol, and medium chain triglycerides.
- Cheap illicit market vape carts also routinely malfunction. Malfunctioning carts can get very hot, and burn additives and thickeners, releasing an unknown noxious gas. Run them at low, controlled temperatures.
- If you’re concerned about additives in your cannabis, stick to tested flowers from licensed adult use stores. Check store licenses on regulators’ websites, like California’s license lookup tool. In terms of extracts, additive-free extract is called “rosin”, and it also comes in vape carts in mature adult use markets. There’s also tinctures, sublinguals, edibles, topicals, and transdermals, for those who want to avoid all cannabinoid inhalation products.
Leafly originally published this story Sept. 6. We updated it again Oct. 17 at 3:15 p.m. PST.