• Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year

    Well balanced, Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year is without a doubt the best rye whiskey on the market. The fact that it comes at an affordable, mid-shelf price point only makes it an even better choice for new and experienced whiskey drinkers alike.

    Upon first inhale, this 115-proof rye reveals an herbal grassiness, as well as both brandied and pleasantly tart cherry. All that’s followed up quickly by sweetness. You may also detect pickle brine, cinnamon, and faint char smoke on the nose.

    Take a sip, and this deep, amber-colored rye presents clove and buttered pickle. On the palate, there’s chocolate and rye cereal. Allow this whiskey to open up, and you’ll be rewarded with cinnamon, baking spices, and oak.  

    There are also notes of toffee, candied fruits, and marmalade. While spice dominates the long, warm, cherry-infused finish, notes of tropical fruit and plenty of barrel spice round out the experience.

    Overall, this 55.0 ABV rye has the sweet notes of bourbon, with plenty of that rye flavor you love. Try Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year, and you’ll agree it’s a great whiskey to drink neat, on the rocks, or mix into an Old Fashioned.

    Pros

    • Mid-shelf price point
    • Rye flavor present
    • Good for mixing

    Cons

    • Sweet
    • High alcohol content
    • 74% rye

    100%Rave Meter

    Shop Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year

  • Ezra Brooks Straight Rye

    Born in Kentucky bourbon country, Ezra Brooks Straight Rye is a 45% ABV, 90-proof, honest-to-goodness rye whiskey—not a lot of fancy stuff goes into the distillation process.

    In fact, Ezra Brooks Straight Rye comes in at an impressive 95% rye, with only 5% barley. But since the spirit is charcoal mellowed before aging in new, charred American oak barrels, the spiciness of the rye is somewhat subdued.

    Instead, this mellowing process brings forward the sweet tastes of vanilla, caramel, oak, and a whole lot more. On the nose, for example, this rye whiskey presents flavors of cedar, white pepper, and some earthy rye spices.

    Try the whiskey, and discover white chocolate and fudge, with rye notes remaining present. And on the finish, you’ll taste apricot and banana chips, with just a little bit of honey.

    All this makes Ezra Brooks Straight Rye a straightforward option for drinking on the rocks. Those seeking big, spicy rye flavors for their mixed drinks might be disappointed—though some enjoy mixing this rye whiskey into a Manhattan.

    Nevertheless, Ezra Brooks Straight Rye is an incredibly affordably priced rye whiskey that belongs on any list of the best rye whiskeys.

    Pros

    • Very inexpensive
    • 95% rye
    • Aged in American oak

    Cons

    • Subdued flavors
    • Not great for mixing
    • Only 90 proof

    99.2%Rave Meter

    Shop Ezra Brooks Straight Rye

  • Angel’s Envy Rum Cask Rye

    Angel’s Envy Rum Cask Rye is a complex spirit that spends up to 18 months finishing in Caribbean rum casks. This is in keeping with Angel’s Envy’s well-known practice of experimenting with different, large-scale barrels.

    The time spent in rum casks gives this whiskey the raw, spicy, and earthy flavors of rye, mixed with the mellow sweetness of rum. The result is silky smooth and immensely drinkable—despite the fact Angel’s Envy is distilled at a formidable 100 proof and is 95% rye!

    The appearance of the whiskey is clear, with a rich, red-amber color. Take an inhale, and enjoy citrus aromas as well as caramel candy, maple sugar, vanilla, oak, hazelnut, baking spice, and sherry wood.

    Let the whiskey linger on the tongue, and the flavor of sweet rum emerges, with more sherry wood and soft oak. There’s also the playful flavor some compare to Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal. And on the finish, the rum cask rye is dry and sweet, with flavors of baking spice and dark fruit.

    Angel’s Envy is a little spendy, so we wouldn’t advise mixing it into your next cocktail. But sip it neat or on the rocks, and you’ll understand why this smooth and nuanced whiskey is among the very best rye whiskeys for seasoned whiskey drinkers and newcomers alike.

    Pros

    • Aged 18 months
    • Finished in Caribbean rum casks
    • Ideal for drinking straight

    Cons

    • Expensive
    • High alcohol content
    • Not ideal for mixing

    98.3%Rave Meter

    Shop Angel’s Envy Rum Cask Rye

  • Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Rye

    At a skull-crushing 104 proof, Rusell’s Reserve is relatively low in rye content—coming in only at about the minimum 51% required to be considered a rye whiskey at all. In a lot of ways, it’s closer to a bourbon than a straight rye whiskey.

    On top of the rye, Russell’s Reserve is 37% corn and 12% barley malt. Nevertheless, Russell’s Reserve, at 52% ABV, delivers balanced spicy pepper, vanilla, and tobacco flavors. And the low rye content makes the whiskey perfect for mixing into any cocktail.

    Non-chill-filtered, Russell’s Reserve is aged in charred American oak barrels.

    Rose-gold and oily in appearance, inhale Russell’s Reserve and find cinnamon, as well as a scent that’s a little like green-apple-flavored hard candy.

    You might also detect sugar, oak, vanilla, leather, cherry, rye, and ethanol. There’s also the subtle yet intense aroma of caramel, earthiness, orange peel, and even a little bit of lime.

    Tasting the whiskey, the apple flavor only grows, as do cherry, big oak, marzipan, herbal rye spice, and mint. There’s also black pepper and cinnamon.

    Let the whiskey linger on the palate, and brown sugar emerges as well as the flavor of rye oak. And it’s all punctuated with lime zest—just to keep you on your toes.

    On the long finish, the whiskey is peppery (and a little buttery), with a rich nuttiness. Drinkers also report cinnamon, cherry, mint, and cedar.

    Given the low rye content, Russell’s Reserve is a perfect mixer—and it doesn’t hurt that it’s also very reasonably priced.

    If you drink Russell’s Reserve straight, you’ll see this rye packs enough heat to be included on any list of the best rye whiskeys.

    Pros

    • Reasonably priced
    • Non-chill filtered
    • Aged in American oak

    Cons

    • Low rye content
    • High alcohol content
    • High corn content

    98%Rave Meter

    Shop Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Rye

  • WhistlePig 10 Year Straight Rye

    One hundred is the only number you need to know before drinking WhistlePig 10 Year Straight Rye. That’s because the whiskey is bottled at 100 proof, and made from 100% rye.

    Despite those big numbers, WhistlePig is very drinkable—though probably too strong for many cocktails.

    WhistlePig ages their 10 Year in new American oak at their farm in Vermont. The whiskey is then finished in used bourbon barrels and bottled by hand.

    This 10 Year is amber-gold in appearance, with allspice on the nose, as well as orange peel, anise, oak, char, and caramel.

    In addition, there are flavors of ginger, nutmeg, clove, and just a little bit of honey. The decade it spends maturating smooths out the flavor of the rye, giving the spirit just a hint of sweetness.

    There are sweet hints of spicy rye and mint on palate. And overall, the taste is full-bodied and warm, with floral notes as well as faint flavors of honey and cinnamon. Mid-palate, there are notes of rye, toffee, and mint.

    The finish is long and warm, revealing butterscotch and caramel. By taking their rye to 100, WhistlePig’s 10 Year is not afraid to tame those bold flavors.

    And it’s definitely one of the best rye whiskeys on the market.

    Pros

    • Aged 10 years
    • 100% rye
    • Aged in new American oak

    Cons

    • Strong rye flavors
    • Not ideal for mixing
    • Higher priced

    97.4%Rave Meter

    Shop WhistlePig 10 Year Straight Rye

  • Old Overholt Bonded Rye

    When you see the word “bonded” in the context of whiskey, as you do with Old Overholt Bonded Rye, it simply means the spirit was made by one distiller, at a single distillery, in one distillation season.

    The term also means the spirit has been aged at least 4 years in a federally bonded and supervised warehouse, to be bottled at 100 proof.

    Old Overholt is very versatile—drink it neat, on the rocks, or mixed into your next cocktail, particularly an Old Fashioned.

    To the eye, Old Overholt  is caramel in color. On the nose, there’s the aroma of sweet caramel as well as copper, rye, grain, butterscotch, fruit, oak, and mint. And under it all, a warm roastiness.

    When you taste this bonded rye, you’ll be greeted with more caramel, roasted grain, cinnamon, oak, and pepper. With good balance and a medium body, there are even the flavors of light vanilla taffy and—perhaps unexpectedly—polenta.

    On the long finish, Old Overholt is spicy, with the flavors of caramel and polenta making a reappearance. It works together to earn Old Overholt a spot on any list of the best rye whiskeys.

    Pros

    • Bonded
    • Versatile
    • Affordable

    Cons

    • Spicy
    • High alcohol content
    • Better mixed

    97.1%Rave Meter

    Shop Old Overholt Bonded Rye

  • Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye

    Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye is unique among rye whiskeys in its use of sweet mash fermentation, as opposed to the much more common sour mash technique. So if you have a sweet tooth, this rye could be for you.

    And at 53.5% ABV, and 107 proof, Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye is a youngster—aged only 24 months in wood. But all this just means this rye is energetic and full of life.

    The unique distillation process results in a well-balanced, smooth whiskey—with the sweet flavor of maple alongside brown sugar and light citrus. On the nose, there are herbal notes, with pine, dill, and grassiness.

    There’s also brown sugar and corn in the mix, as well as woodiness, apple, salinity, and a little heat of alcohol. On the palate, there’s a strong alcohol presence. It’s also woodsy, with notes of pine, fruit, sweet corn, and brown sugar.

    Sampling this straight rye reminds some of a cinnamon or molasses cookie. And the sweetness continues on the finish, with vanilla toffee, crème brûlée, pepper, oak, and spice.

    Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye might be too sweet for some, and it’s not ideal for mixing. But try it neat or on the rocks, and you’ll agree it’s one of the best rye whiskeys available.

    Pros

    • Sweet mash fermentation
    • Aged 24 months
    • Best sampled straight

    Cons

    • Expensive
    • Sweet
    • Not ideal for mixing

    96.1%Rave Meter

    Shop Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye

  • Rittenhouse Rye

    Produced in the classic Pennsylvania (or Monongahela) tradition, Rittenhouse Rye has a spicy and fruity flavor profile, despite having relatively low rye content of only 51%.  

    Nevertheless, Rittenhouse Rye, bottled at 100 proof and bonded, has a nice mixture of fruit and grain on the nose, with banana, peach, and malty grain—an aroma some describe as being a little like a nice, comforting bowl of oatmeal.

    Upon tasting this rye, there’s peach and dried banana, mixed nicely with spice and pepper. Rittenhouse Rye has a relatively mellow flavor among ryes, steering more toward the side of mellow and fruity, without a heavy mouthfeel.  

    This rye whiskey is well balanced, with a lingering finish of maple and honeysuckle—along with light char, peach, pepper, and rye spice. The alcohol provides some heat up front, but it never becomes overly hot or too spicy.

    Mellow and fruity, Rittenhouse may not be the rye whiskey for someone looking for big, bold rye flavors. Still, Rittenhouse Rye is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a mellow, fruity whiskey to mix in their next cocktail. And you can’t beat the low price! It’s one one of the best—and most affordable—rye whiskeys on the market.

    Pros

    • “Monongahela” style
    • Well balanced
    • Affordable

    Cons

    • Low rye content
    • High alcohol content
    • Mellow flavors

    95.9%Rave Meter

    Shop Rittenhouse Rye

  • Michter’s 10 Year Rye

    If you’re looking for a rye whiskey that makes no apologies for being a rye, look no further than Michter’s 10 Year.

    Single barrel, and bottled at 92.8 proof and 46.4 ABV, Michter’s 10 Year is aged for a decade in fire-charred, new American white oak barrels, resulting in flavors of vanilla and toffee, toasted almonds and cinnamon, with pepper and just a hint of orange citrus.

    Amber in color, Michter’s 10 Year has copper on the nose, with dill, spice, toffee, sweetness, butterscotch, banana, and dried fruit.

    On the palate, Michter’s really coats the tongue—with forward flavors of smoke, wood, leather, rosemary, thyme, and mint.

    The whiskey then turns sweet as flavors of vanilla, coffee, and pleasantly bittersweet chocolate emerge. And it all winds down to a medium finish, revealing coppery butterscotch, dried fruit, and spearmint.

    Fans of Michter’s say this is a whiskey for those who aren’t afraid to feel the burn of alcohol—in other words, it’s not for whiskey beginners. But if you’re looking for a bold rye whiskey to drink neat or on the rocks, Michter’s is the best rye whiskey for you.

    Pros

    • Aged 10 years
    • Aged in new American white oak
    • Best straight

    Cons

    • Strong rye flavors
    • Not ideal for mixing
    • Expensive

    95.3%Rave Meter

    Shop Michter’s 10 Year Rye

  • George Dickel Rye

    If you’re planning a Mad Men-style, swinging ’60s party, you need a bottle of George Dickel Rye in your home bar. This is because George Dickel mellows their rye in a distinctive, chilled charcoal style, giving the whiskey a smooth finish, despite being 95% rye and 5% malted barley.

    At 90 proof, and 45% ABV, George Dickel’s is still smooth, making it a great choice for classic cocktails such as Manhattans or Old Fashioneds.

    This whiskey is gold in color and grassy on the nose. On first inhale, there’s also nuttiness, caramel corn, and an herbal aroma a little like tea.

    Taste the whiskey, and experience the smoothness, as well as fruity notes like cherry, and a little heat of peppercorn. It’s all sweet, a little like a bourbon.

    And at the finish, George Dickel goes from sweet to savory—and a bit fiery at the very end. An easy drinker, George Dickel is without question the best rye whiskey to mix in your next cocktail.

    Pros

    • Very smooth
    • Easy to mix
    • Very affordable

    Cons

    • Not ideal straight
    • Sweet, like bourbon
    • Mellow flavors

    95%Rave Meter

    Shop George Dickel Rye