The Moral Dilemma of Cannabis Analysis on Pregnancy


When researchers at the University of Washington (UW) announced their plans to conduct a study on the effects of cannabis use on pregnant ladies with nausea and morning sickness, it sparked an quick backlash — 1 that highlighted the moral dilemma of conducting cannabis investigation on vulnerable human subjects. 

The study, which started its initial stages in February 2019 and will continue till 2021, will evaluate the effects of cannabis and regular anti-nausea medicines on a group of 70 ladies in between the ages of 21 and 34. The cannabis-applying subjects, chosen from a group of volunteers, will be needed to use cannabis at least twice a week, and are needed to buy their solutions (the study does not specify which ones could or could not be made use of) only from licensed dispensaries. The ladies will supply everyday reports on their mood, levels of nausea, and cannabis use. After their babies are six months old, the mothers will bring them back for behavioral assessments and an MRI. According to the study’s authors, “We do not anticipate to come across something of healthcare concern.” The ladies will be paid $300 every single to participate in the study. 

Ethan Zohn Story: The Survivor

According to the study’s co-lead author, Dr. Natalia Kleinhans, the advantage for these ladies (aside from the little quantity of income and the cost-free healthcare consultations) is the chance to “help supply trustworthy facts to other individuals who want to make informed choices about their pregnancies in the future.” But with so a lot potentially at stake, quite a few view this as an underwhelming payoff. 

Does a Require for Extra Analysis on Cannabis and Pregnancy Outweigh the Dangers?

On 1 hand, human research are crucial for figuring out the accurate dangers and/or advantages of cannabis use. There’s an undeniable gap in scientists’ understanding of how cannabis impacts humans, in particular precise demographics such as pregnant ladies. And with additional ladies applying cannabis through pregnancy, the need to have for additional facts is in particular urgent. 

A 2019 paper published in JAMA Network Open identified that self-reported cannabis use amongst pregnant ladies rose from 1.9 % to three.four % in between the years 2009-2017, and Dr. Kelly Young-Wolff, the study’s lead author, mentioned that “[the] actual numbers are probably greater, as ladies could be unwilling to disclose their substance use to a healthcare expert.”

This is probably linked to the spread of legal cannabis across the nation — and the increasing belief that the plant poses couple of overall health dangers. According to a 2015 study in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, about 70 % of all ladies (each pregnant and nonpregnant) “believe there is slight or no danger of harm from applying marijuana as soon as or twice a week.” 

Considering that the healthcare cannabis applications of quite a few states consist of extreme nausea as an authorized situation for prescription, this has led some to think that cannabis is protected for anybody dealing with this concern. In reality, a 2018 study in the journal Obstetrics and Gynecology identified that virtually 70 % of cannabis dispensary workers in Colorado had advised cannabis to pregnant ladies to treat their nausea. On the other hand, this self-confidence is not shared by quite a few medical doctors.

As Dr. Nancy Goler, OB/GYN, told Science Each day, “Until such time as we completely have an understanding of the precise overall health dangers cannabis poses for pregnant ladies and their fetuses, we are recommending stopping all cannabis use prior to conceiving and definitely as soon as a lady knows she is pregnant.”

The Ethics of Cannabis Analysis and Pregnancy

Goler’s stance is widespread amongst healthcare experts — the Centers for Illness Handle and Prevention (CDC), the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) all strongly discourage cannabis use through pregnancy. On the other hand, it also illustrates the catch-22 of researching the effects of cannabis on pregnancy: Without having conducting extended-term research on a sizable quantity of human subjects, there’s no way for scientists to attain firm conclusions on regardless of whether or not cannabis is protected for pregnant ladies.

This was the justification provided by Kleinhans, the co-lead author of the UW study. She also pointed out the limitations of current investigation on cannabis and pregnancy. ““The incredibly couple of investigations that have studied prenatal cannabis exposure and infant brain improvement have all involved ladies who are polysubstance drug customers. No 1 has looked at marijuana use exclusively.” As such, it is complicated to say regardless of whether the unfavorable side effects identified by these research had been brought on by cannabis, or 1 or additional of the other substances that they consumed.

On the other hand, even though there could be some uncertainty that cannabis was the ultimate lead to of these side effects, preceding research have shown they are extreme sufficient to make 1 query if risking the overall health of pregnant ladies and their unborn kids in the name of science is worth it. A report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) identified that cannabis use through pregnancy could be correlated to reduce birth weights, even though a different from researchers at Washington State University showed that the offspring of rats who had been provided cannabis through pregnancy had impaired brain improvement. 

These research have clear limitations — though the former identified that cannabis could influence birth weight, it also identified that “the connection with other pregnancy and childhood outcomes is unclear,” even though the latter was not carried out on humans. In spite of this, the query remains: do the possible advantages to future generations outweigh the possible harms to human beings in the present moment?

It is a matter for debate — and really serious soul-browsing.


Latest posts